Saturday, 17 March 2012

Credit Crisis: Causes and Implications



An article from the Financial Times in 2008 suggested that one cause of the crisis was because banks were increasingly using an ‘originate and distribute’ model. Although this spread risk across the financial system it also weakened credit assessment.  There was not one company or person but many interrelated events which occurred and decisions made which led to the crisis.  The start of the crisis could date back as far as 2005 with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac who wanted to make housing more affordable.  They were given an incentive by the Government who facilitated the extension of many risky mortgages which were not definitely going to be paid back.  This led to a ‘subprime housing bubble’.  In 2007 New Century Financial which also specialised in sub-prime mortgages filed for bankruptcy and halves its workforce.  Just months later Sachsen Landesbank was also near bankruptcy as it had invested in the sub-prime market.  This occurred due to decrease in housing prices and increased interest rates and therefore many loans defaulted but the value of the properties were worth much less than the mortgage loan.  Other potential causes of the crisis were investment banks and hedge funds caused by increased leverage.  But liquidity started to decrease leading to difficulty in finding funding and banks refusing to lend to each other.  Bear Stearns could not give investors any money due to lack of lending from banks and BNP Paribas were unable to make money available to investors due to evaporation of liquidity.

The credit crisis caused huge concern when the major repercussions hit the UK in 2007.  From august 2007 the cost of credit increased making it difficult both for businesses and the public to get access to equity funds.  This led to many consequences such as the decline in house prices and share prices which led to decline in personal wealth and business wealth and value.   Much uncertainty accumulated during this time which led people to save instead of spending which of course affected business income and profitability.
The credit crisis has not only changed the way in which people spend their money it has also meant huge implications to businesses. Lending has significantly decreased. Marlin Steel Wire Products applied for just $175,000 increase in credit but even though it is a profitable company they were refused it unless the company put an equal sum into a certificate of deposit (Bloomberg Business Week, 2008).   

This lack in credit and spending from consumers leads to cash flow problems, which can often lead to job cuts.  The Allied Irish Bank announced earlier this year it was to cut 2,500 jobs (The Guardian, 2012).  Fujitsu announced 1,200 job losses due to economic downturn in 2009 showing a loss of 29.2 billion yen in three months from april to june 2009 due to fall in sales (Telegraph, 2009).  Since October 2008 UK job losses were over 154,000 (Telegraph, 2008). 


With unemployment figures reaching the highest in 17 years (BBC News, 2012) consumer spending is also decreasing with UK retail sales down 0.3% on like for like basis last year.  Argos sales decreased 10% in June 2011 and are expecting a fifth consecutive year of decreased profit.  The Johnson Cleaners chain has also seen decline in revenues down 1.8% and says the cause is the economic climate as wages remain stagnant, increasing inflation and decline in spending on luxury services (The Guardian, 2012).  The travel Industry was hard hit with people and businesses less willing to spend on such expensive luxury.  Rome saw hotel occupancy decline 17.5% in October 2008 compared to the same time the previous year and in London hotel occupancy fell 5.2%.  Hotel Occupancy in Europe declined 6.3% in October 2008.  International Air Transportation Association reported decline of international passenger traffic of 1.3% in October 2008 compared to October 2007 and saw a further drop of 2.9% in September 2008 (msnbc, 2008). The fact so many different countries and industries are affected shows the extent of the crisis Worldwide not just in the countries hit the most by the crisis such as UK and US.
The number of companies failing since the economic crisis is shown below.  Businesses affected include well known brands such as Zavvi/Virgin, Jane Norman, Floors-2-Go, Barratts, MFI  and Woolworths.

Year     Number of business failures               Number of employees affected
2007    25                                                        14,083
2008    54                                                        74,539
2009    37                                                        26,688
2010    26                                                        10,930

There is a huge affect for everyone including people and businesses when a recession hits.  Just some of the affects are shown here and it clearly shows a declining spiral.  Neither businesses nor public can borrow therefore both reduce spending.  When consumers spend less the business profits decline which can lead to cash flow problems.  As the business can not borrow money it has to save money by reducing costs.  This is usually done by closing stores and cutting jobs.  This leads to higher unemployment and less people earning and therefore even less spending.  The UK need to find a way to prevent this from continuing.  The obvious way would seem to be to create jobs and therefore more people will be able to afford to spend but as the causes explained are complex it is also a complex situation to end.  China were not hit as hard as the US and UK at the start of the crisis.  The financial Times reports that this is because China is pushing financial reforms to lead to a more active domestic capital market.  China have expanded its domestic bond market and opened a stock exchange for small businesses and encouraged greater international use of its currency the renminbi.  India has reduced government stakes in banks and raised its limit of foreign investment for insurers to attract foreign capital to help investment and growth in India.  With an influx of money it is also helping increase their currency value against the dollar (Financial Times, 2009).  

The US has seen increase in investment in equities over the last year with the figure rising to $3.7bn, the second highest total in 10 years (Financial Times, 2011).  However it is not going to be enough for a full recovery.  It could however be a route to help recovery and maybe the UK should look at China and India and the increased investment in the US and try to make itself more attractive for FDI by making the UK more attractive to invest in.  This may mean looking at reforming some of its financial policies.

References